Courts & Tribunals
In March 2009, Head of Colombia Diversa Marcela Sánchez said that compliance with the court decision "is not automatic, and we have to demand government measures to help the content of the ruling overcome prejudices, and to assist people who don’t know how to use what they have never had" [R2.1].
In January 2009, the Constitutional Court ruled that gay and lesbian couples in Colombia are entitled to the same rights as straight couples in common-law marriages [R2.2].
In April 2008, Colombia’s Constitutional Court ruled that the government must extend pension benefits to same-sex partners, finding that to exclude same-sex partners would violate the principle of non-discrimination and human dignity as the expression of personal autonomy, protected by international law [R2.3].
Previously:
In 1996, the Colombian Constitutional Court was reported to have ruled that Lesbian and gay couples are barred from health, retirement and other state benefits granted to straight couples [R2.4].
On 11 October 2001, the Colombian Supreme Court issued a verdict in favor of conjugal visitation rights for Alba Nelly Montoya, a lesbian in prison, and her partner [C2] [R2.5].
The Court mandated that the director of Risaralda Women´s Prison - where Ms. Montoya is carrying her sentence - make all necessary arrangements for the lesbian visit to take place, in conditions that are equal to those of heterosexual visits, ruling that depriving lesbian inmates of conjugal visits violates their constitutionally protected rights to privacy (Article 15 of the Colombian Constitution), to freedom from discrimination based on sex, and to equality before the law (Article 13 of the Colombian Constitution).
The judges also stated that allowing conjugal visits to lesbian women in prison--under the same conditions of privacy and security required for heterosexual visits--constitutes no threat to the prison regime or to the well-being of other inmates or visitors, including children.
In November 2002, a judge in Manizales finally granted Marta Alvarez, a lesbian imprisoned in Caldas, visitation rights from her partner in Manizales [R2.6].
In granting the petition the judge invoked women's rights to equality, privacy and free development of their personalities.
Previously:
In May 2002, despite the Supreme Court decision in the Montoya Case (above) the Armenia Women's Jail continued to deny the right to conjugal visitations to the female partner of inmate Ms. Marta Lucia Alvarez Giraldo [R2.7].
The Marta Alvarez case (#11656) was heard at the Interamerican Commission on Human Rights (IAHRC) on October 1, 1999, after all legal recourses in Colombia had been exhausted over the preceding five years |