|
| Age of Consent | Legislation/Cases/References |
| 1. |
National
In July 2000, the gay age of consent in Israel was lowered from 18 to 16 [R1.1].
The change brings the gay age of consent in line with the age of consent for heterosexuals.
The amendment to the penal code also exempts consensual gay sex involving youths 14 and 15 and youths up to three years older. |
|
|
|
|
Assisted Reproduction Technology Artificial Insemination, In Vitro Fertilisation, Surrogacy | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
On 19 March 2013, the Health Ministry Implementation Committee adopted a court recommendation to recognize both members of gay couples as parents of children born with the aid of overseas surrogacy [R1.5].
On 20 May 2012, the public committee for regulation of issues of fertility and childbirth published a report recommended that same-sex couples should be able to become the legal parents of surrogate children. The report must be approved by the Health Ministry before it can be forwarded to the Knesset for legislation [R1.4].
On 06 April 2012, it was reported that the public committee to regulate issues of fertility and childbirth in Israel – chaired by Professor Shlomo Mor-Yosef and comprising of 11 lawyers, doctors and public figures – will recommend to the Health Ministry to allow same-sex couples to qualify for surrogacy in Israel [R1.3].
As at November 2011, only heterosexual couples are authorized to undergo the surrogacy procedure and the Health Ministry committee was yet to recommend authorizing same-sex couple surrogacy following a petition to the High Court of Justice 18 months ago [R1.2].
In December 2009, the Israeli Health Ministry was reportedly considering allowing gay couples to have a child through surrogate mothers, according to ministry legal adviser Mira Huebner-Harel. Since 1996 surrogacy for heterosexual couples has been lawful [R1.1]. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 03 February 2013, High Court of Justice recommended the state clarifies legal procedures for gay couples seeking surrogacy, as a legal framework does not exist and this amounts to discrimination [C2.3], [R2.2].
On 09 February 2012, same-sex couple Itay Pinkas and Yoav Arad reportedly petitioned the High Court with a request that the State be ordered to allow them to become parents through surrogacy [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Asylum, Immigration, Migration, Refugees | Legislation/Cases/References |
| 1. |
National
Israel allows an Israeli citizen to sponsor the residency application of their same-sex partner [R1.6].
Previously:
In 2000, Israel quietly began allowing gay citizens' foreign lovers to immigrate [R1.5].
At a Knesset Committee on the Status of Women, the Interior Ministry's Batya Carmon said immigration officials now treat same-sex couples the same as common-law spouses.
A foreign partner must present a request at the district office of the Interior Ministry along with proof of the relationship. The individual will receive a one-year tourist permit that allows employment.
After four years (during which the tourist permit is renewed annually), the individual can request temporary resident status. Several years later, he or she can seek permanent residency and, eventually apply for citizenship.
On 10 August 2011, the Interior Ministry reportedly granted citizenship to Bayardo Alvarez, a non-Jewish gay man married to Jewish man Joshua Goldberg, for the first time applying the Law of Return to a spouse in same-sex marriage. It is unclear whether move sets precedent [R1.4].
In July 2011, a special exceptions committee, headed by Director of the Interior Ministry's Population and Immigration Administration Amnon Ben-Ami, reportedly approved providing a foreign partner of an Israeli diplomat with a diplomatic passport and Israeli citizenship, allowing him also to join his partner on his mission abroad [R1.3].
In June 2011, Joshua Goldberg and Bayardo Alvarez, both American citizens, emigrated to Israel. Goldberg, who is Jewish, received an Israeli identity card and immigrant certificate on arrival, under the Law of Return. Alvarez, despite exerting much pressure on the ministry, was granted only temporary residence [R1.2].
In April 2008, in a rare occurrence, the interior ministry granted a gay Palestinian man a temporary permit to live with his Israeli partner [R1.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Children: Access, Custody, Visitation | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 19 March 2001, the Israeli High Court of Justice overturned a rabbinical court ruling that prohibited a lesbian from seeing her children from a heterosexual marriage if her female lover was present [R1.3].
In September 2000, the High Court of Justice had asked Attorney-General Elyakim Rubinstein for his opinion on whether the district and supreme rabbinic courts were empowered to issue a ruling banning a lesbian from spending time with the biological children of her partner [R1.2].
Justices Theodore Or and Yitzchak Zamir and Acting Justice Ayala Procaccia added that if Rubinstein determined that the rabbinic courts did not have the right to rule on the matter, the High Court ruling will automatically go in favor of the couple who petitioned the court against the rabbinic decision without recourse to another hearing. [R1.2]
In early 1999, a judge in the Family Court of Israel granted each of two woman in a lesbian relationship custody rights for each of their non-biological children [R1.1].
This was the first precedent in Israel which granted recognition, even though limited, of the lesbian family. |
|
|
|
|
| Civil Unions, Partners: Domestic, Registered | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
Currently, Israelis may be recognized as civily married if they are civily married overseas, and then apply for recognition of their status by the Interior Ministry upon their return [R3.3].
Effective November 2010, the Civil Union Law was passed in March, enabling Israelis with no officially defined religion to join a civil union recognized by the state. The four recognized religions in Israel are Judaism, Islam, Christianity and the Druse faith [R3.3].
In 2002, the chairman of the house committee in Israel's Knesset, Yossi Katz of the Labor Party, proposed altering the Israeli parliament's rules to ensure that gay partners of Knesset members have the same rights as their heterosexual counterparts [R1.2].
In 1994, same sex unions were recognized for benefit purposes [R1.1]. |
| 2. |
Cities & Towns
In 2002, the Tel Aviv municipality [regulations] did not discriminate against a person in the conferral of services due to his personal status. The municipality treats couples known to the public, including single sex couples, as couples in every sense, and will confer to them the same discounts and benefits in public services which are provided to married couples [R2.1].
Persons seeking benefits under the new regulations will have to submit an affidavit, signed by an attorney, to the municipality. Copies of the declaration form on the municipality's internet site [R2.1] |
| 3. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 17 October 2012, the High Court judges upheld the Civil Union Law, enabling Israelis with no officially defined religion to join in a civil union recognized by the state. Nevertheless, the court commented in various parts of the ruling on the perceived restrictive imperfections in the law, leaving the door open for the issue to be revisited in the future [R3.3].
On 03 May 2010, the Tel Aviv District Labor Court ordered the Makefet pension fund to pay a survivor's pension to the surviving partner even though the partners hid their relationship from family members. The court also ruled that same-sex couples should not have the burdensome task of proving that they are in a committed relationship in order to collect such benefits, even if the relationship is a secret among family and acquaintances [R3.2].
In July 2007, after the death of her partner, a 64-year-old lesbian in Israel was granted a widow's pension by the Israeli government [R3.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Discrimination | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
On 19 February 2012, MK Nitzan Horowitz (Meretz) delayed a vote on his bill prohibiting discrimination based on sexual orientation, so that advocacy groups for the LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual, transsexual) community can convince ministers to approve the legislation [R1.2].
In 1992, discrimination in employment based on sexual orientation became unlawful [R1.1]. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 12 September 2012, Judge Dorit Feinstein in the Jerusalem Magistrates' Court ruled that the owners of the Moshav Yad Hashmona events hall must pay Tal Ya'akovovich and Yael Biran $15,000 for refusing to host the lesbian couple's wedding reception on ideological grounds, plus legal fees and court costs [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Estates, Inheritance, Property, Succession, Wills | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
In 2006, under a new proposal by the Israeli government, gay and lesbian couples in Israel would be able to inherit each other's property after death without making a special court application [R1.3].
However, Israel's Justice Minister reportedly revised a draft law on inheritance law for cohabiting unmarried couple to specifically exclude gay and lesbian couples [R1.2].
In February 2002, the Income Tax Authority asked the attorney general to support a lenient interpretation of the inheritance law that would allow same-sex partners to transfer property rights from one to the other without having to pay a tax [R1.1].
By law, the transfer of real estate between partners is tax free, but the language of the law refers to heterosexual couples. The Income Tax Authority, which implements a liberal policy in regard to the sexual makeup of the family unit, would like to allow same-sex couples enjoy the same benefits as do other couples. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
In May 2011, the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court set a legal precedent, declaring a gay Holocaust survivor's life partner was eligible to inherit his entire estate – including his restitution payments [R2.2].
In October 2003, an Israeli tribunal ruled that a gay man cannot claim his deceased partner's inheritance deeming that an Israeli law that recognizes an inheritance right for unmarried sexual partners applies only to heterosexual couples [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
Gender Identity, Intersex, Transgender, Transexual
| Legislation/Cases/References |
| 1. |
National
As at 06 May 2003, the Interior Ministry reportedly only permits individuals to alter the sex listed on their identity card or change their name after presentation of a certificate that confirms that they have had a sex change operation. |
|
|
|
|
| Homosexuality, Sodomy | Legislation/Cases/References |
| 1. |
National
In 1988, consensual sex between male same-sex couples was lawful [R1.2].
The law apparently does not mention lesbian couples [R1.2].
In December 1999, the then Health Minister Shiomo Benizri said that gays are sick deviants [R1.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Marriage | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
On 27 January 2013, MK Nitzan Horowitz of Meretz was reportedly preparing to submit a same-sex marriage law to the next Knesset [R1.3].
On 16 May 2012, the Knesset, which is responsible for passing all laws in Israel, threw out legislation put forward by Nitzan Horowitz, of the left-wing Meretz party, which would allow same-sex as well as inter-faith couples to wed [R1.2].
In August 2000, legislation to grant legal recognition to couples whose marriages are not recognized by the rabbinate reportedly would not be extended to include gay and lesbian couples [R1.1]. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 02 December 2012, the Ramat Gan Family Court granted the divorce of Professor Avi Even and Dr. Amit Kama, who married in Canada in 2004, setting a new precedent in rejecting argument that only the rabbinical courts have the authority to dissolve marriage [R2.2].
In September 2000, recognizing a same-sex marriage was considered not to be within the scope of the family court system, according to a legal opinion submitted to the Ramat Gan Family Court on behalf of Attorney-General Elyakim Rubinstein [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Military | Legislation/Cases/References |
| 1. |
National
On 15 August 2011, a study was released in which LGBT soldiers in the Israeli Defense Force were asked about their treatment throughout the induction process and 40% said they have been subjected to verbal attacks, while 20% claim to have been physically or sexually assaulted [R1.4].
As at February 2006, Israeli teenagers are required to serve in the nation's military. But they can seek an exemption for various reasons and sign up for a national service agency instead, a popular option for among women in the religious population [R1.3].
In 1993, the Israeli government lifted the ban on openly gay men and lesbians joining the services [R1.2].
In July 2000, a study by U.S. researchers found that the presence of gay and lesbian soldiers in the Israeli military did not affect combat readiness, unit cohesion, or military preparedness [R1.2] [R1.1]. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 13 February 2013, a court appeals committee headed by Judge Shlomit Jakubowicz instructed the defense ministry to compensate Julie Algavassi, a 3 year-old girl who lost her lesbian mother's partner Faviola Bohadana in a fire incident, ruling the step-child was a dependent at the time of her step-mother's death [R2.3].
In March 1997, the Israeli Defence Force was appealing a District Court Appeals Committee ruling that gave a military spousal pension to Adir Steiner, a gay man whose male lover, Colonel Doron Meisel died of cancer in 1991 [R2.2].
Previously:
In January 1997, the District Court ordered the army to recognise a gay man as the spouse of a deceased male colonel and extend him the same benefits as military widows [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Parenting, Adoption, Fostering | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
On 12 May 2013, Attorney General Yehudi Weinstein reportedly ruled that pending the finalization of proper legislation, family courts will be able to issue a court order recognizing a non-biological father's parenthood following a genetic test proving the parenthood of the biological father of children conceived through a surrogacy process and other conditions to be further elaborated in future legislation, without the previous need for a lengthy and complex adoption process [R1.3].
On 19 March 2013, the Health Ministry Implementation Committee adopted a court recommendation to recognize both members of gay couples as parents of children born with the aid of overseas surrogacy [R1.2].
On 17 May 2010, prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu intervened on the side of gay father Don Goldberg stranded in India with his twin sons, overruling the judge's decision. "I spoke this morning with the Interior Ministry and instructed it to relax the law and let the family return to Israel," Netanyahu said [R1.1].
See 2. Courts & Tribunals [R2.11], [R2.10]. |
| 2. |
Courts & Tribunals
On 04 March 2012, Judge Alyssa Miller, of Ramat Gan Family Court, ruled that a lesbian couple who underwent a medical procedure with the permission of the government six years ago, in which the egg of one woman was fertilized with the sperm of an anonymous donor and implanted in the womb of her partner, both be recognized as the mothers of a baby boy [R2.13].
On 16 December 2010, the Jerusalem Family Court ruled that the partner of a man could adopt a child born two years go to the man via a surrogate mother in India [R2.12].
In October 2010, a judicial ombudsman called the judge's handling in the case in which a gay Israeli man who earlier fathered twins with an Indian surrogate before being denied entry back into the country with his children, "unnecessary, hurtful, and beyond the bounds of appropriate behavior" [R2.11].
In May 2010, the Jerusalem family court denied a gay Israeli man, Don Goldberg, reentry into the country with his twin sons, Itai and Liron, born to a surrogate mother in India, pending a paternity test to confirm that he is their father [R2.10].
However, see 1. State [R1.1].
In March 2009, a Tel Aviv family court ruled that a gay couple can adopt the son they took in 14 years ago [R2.9].
In March 2008, the Family Court in Tel Aviv ruled that a gay couple can both register to be their adopted son's father [R2.8].
In December 2007, Israel's Supreme Court said the government must recognise foreign adoptions by same-sex parents [R2.7].
In May 2000, the High Court of Justice allowed a lesbian spouse to be registered as the second parent of her partner's biological son [R2.6].
In January 2005, the Supreme Court ruled that a lesbian couple is able to legally adopt each other's children [R2.5].
In November 2005, the Be'er Sheva Family Court ruled that a lesbian woman can adopt her female partner's daughter [R2.4].
In 2002, a homosexual couple petitioned the High Court of Justice requesting that it instruct the Interior Ministry to register both men as fathers of a child they have adopted in the US where the authorities registered both men as the fathers of the boy [R2.3] [R2.2].
In August 1999, a request by a lesbian couple for co-adoption of their non-biological children was denied by the Family Court in Israel [R2.1]. |
|
|
|
|
| Taxation | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
In February 2002, the Income Tax Authority asked the attorney general to support a lenient interpretation of the inheritance law that would allow same-sex partners to transfer property rights from one to the other without having to pay a tax [R1.1].
By law, the transfer of real estate between partners is tax free, but the language of the law refers to heterosexual couples. The Income Tax Authority, which implements a liberal policy in regard to the sexual makeup of the family unit, would like to allow same-sex couples enjoy the same benefits as do other couples. |
|
|
|
|
| Violence, Bullying, Domestic Violence, Harassment, Vilification | Legislation/Cases/References |
|
| 1. |
National
In April 1998, the Israeli Knesset passed a law that bans anti-gay sexual harassment and other anti-gay actions in the workplace and all other facets of life.
Violators face civil and criminal penalities as high as two years in prison.
"Sexual harassment" is defined, in part, as "a despising or humiliating attitude that is shown toward a person regarding his sex or sexuality, including his sexual orientation." [R1.1].
Quaere does the use of the words "his" and
his sexual orientation" thereby exclude lesbians? |
|
|
|
|
|
|